
Archie Brown, Julie Newton, Matthew Evangelista
.png)
The term, Cold War, is a figurative way of describing the reality of political, economic and military struggle for supremacy – by all means short of full-scale hot war – between Western democracies and the Communist states of the Soviet Union and Eastern Europe. (From 1948, China was a significant player in the Cold War, but its Communist regime had independent standing and, especially in the 1960s, ’70s and ’80s an often tense relationship with Moscow, in which Beijing challenged the Soviet claim to leadership of the International Communist Movement.) In spite of spasmodic regional proxy wars, in which the two main antagonists, the US and the USSR, avoided direct conflict between their armed forces, the Cold War was not the kind of confrontation whose ending can be pinned down to a day the guns fell silent and no missiles were launched.
However, the most important manifestation of the Cold War was the existence of Communist states in East-Central Europe. The US and Britain, allies of the Soviet Union in World War II from 1941 to 1945, accepted the notion of a Soviet sphere of influence in Eastern Europe, but not the imposition of Soviet-type Communist regimes whose leaderships were subordinate to Moscow and dependent on the continuing support of their Soviet overlords. Prior to the perestroika era, any attempt by an East-Central European country to pursue an independent path brought Soviet-led reprisals, all the way up to military invasion in Hungary in 1956 and Czechoslovakia in 1968.
It is the end of 1989 which should be regarded as marking also the end of the Cold War. In the course of that year, one country after another in Central and East Europe removed its Communist leaders and became non-Communist and independent, Poland, Hungary and (in late December) Czechoslovakia prominent among them. The Gorbachev leadership in Moscow acquiesced in these profound changes, and Soviet troops remained in their barracks, as they did when the Berlin Wall was opened (and subsequently demolished) in November 1989, signalling the beginning of the end of East Germany’s Communist regime and presaging German unification in 1990. FULL THREAD

The Cold War did indeed end. Its structural conditions were removed by 1989: the Berlin Wall fell, Soviet forces voluntarily withdrew from Eastern Europe, the Warsaw Pact was dismantled, Germany reunified within NATO with Soviet consent, and in 1991 the Soviet Union itself dissolved peacefully with relatively little bloodshed. The struggle for Europe, which had been at the core of the Cold War since 1947-48, was over.
To deny this ending — and to insist that the Cold War merely paused, transformed, or never really stopped — is to ignore the ideational (by which I mean the role of ideas, values, beliefs, and identity) and structural changes that Gorbachev unleashed, and that the US and USSR concluded together. At the ideational level, Gorbachev's "New Thinking" (novoye myshleniye) constituted a genuine ideological rupture: the explicit rejection of Marxism-Leninism's class struggle as the basis of Soviet foreign policy; the embrace of "all-human values" over systemic ideological cleavage; the re-conceptualisation of security as mutual rather than zero-sum. Without this prior shift in thinking, without the willingness to relinquish the ideological framework that had justified Soviet imperial control over Eastern Europe, the peaceful structural transformations of 1989-1990 are impossible to explain satisfactorily. The Wall did not fall when and how it did because of material pressures (economic, systemic, or external) alone. Those pressures interacted with Gorbachev's embrace of "new thinking," his conviction that the use of force to preserve the Soviet empire was illegitimate, to produce a transformation that neither set of factors could have brought about on its own. FULL THREAD

The political-ideological Cold War ended with the exhaustion of Soviet-style state socialism, but the apparent victory of market-oriented democracy was short-lived. Elite-led globalization and neoliberalism proved antithetical to genuine democratic practice and contributed to vast disparities in wealth and income. The result for domestic politics was not the flourishing of democracy that some observers heralded, but almost a convergence of political systems into hybrid electoral autocracies with quasi-market economies run by corrupt oligarchs—far from the vision of the reformers and activists who promoted the end of the ideological Cold War.
The geopolitical and military Cold War in Europe seemed to end with the fall of the Berlin Wall, the peaceful overthrow of communist regimes in Eastern Europe, the unification of Germany, the withdrawal of Soviet military forces, the breakup of the Warsaw Pact, and the disintegration of the Soviet Union itself. From the vantage point of a quarter century, it now seems more that the geopolitical-military divide just shifted East. Contrary to the aspirations of the Soviet reformers, members of the European Nuclear Disarmament movement, and many East European human-rights activists, there was no mutual dissolution of military blocs to make Europe whole, free, and peaceful. Instead NATO expanded, both geographically in Europe, and globally with its involvement in US-led wars in the Middle East and Afghanistan. Russia’s interference in Ukraine and annexation of Crimea in 2014 sought to reestablish the sphere of influence that Mikhail Gorbachev voluntarily gave up. The full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022 ignited a war in central Europe that has already outlasted the Nazi-Soviet war of 1941-1945. Renewed emphasis on nuclear weapons even among non-nuclear members of NATO, combined with Putin’s nuclear saber-rattling, has made the military situation in Europe as dangerous as during the darkest days of the Cold War—or more so, since Russia’s aggressive expansionism has been demonstrated, whereas the Soviet Union’s was mainly imagined. FULL THREAD
November 15, 2026
20261115-weave-brown-newton-evangelista-part-three
A close-up

Archie Brown is Emeritus Professor of Politics at the University of Oxford, a Fellow of the British Academy, and an International Honorary Member of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences. His books include The Gorbachev Factor (1996), Seven Years that Changed the World: Perestroika in Perspective (2007), The Rise and Fall of Communism (2009), The Myth of the Strong Leader: Political Leadership in the Modern Age (2014), and The Human Factor: Gorbachev, Reagan, and Thatcher, and the End of the Cold War (2020).
Julie Newton is the Principal Investigator of the University Consortium (UC), a ten-year interregional initiative based at St Antony’s and funded by the Andrew Carnegie Foundation, New York. She is also a Research Fellow at the Russian and Eurasian Studies Centre, St Antony's College, University of Oxford (where she received her DPhil), and a Visiting Professor of Russian foreign policy at Colorado College. She was previously an Associate Professor in the Politics and History Department at the American University of Paris for 15 years. Her research centres on Russia-West relations, Russian foreign policy, and the intellectual networks of Russian foreign policy elites. She has co-edited Institutions, Ideas, and Leadership in Russian Politics with Bill Thompson (Palgrave Macmillan, 2010) and authored Russia, France, and the Idea of Europe (Palgrave Macmillan, 2003), along with numerous journal articles. Current and forthcoming work includes the chapter "Russia's Alternative Voices of the early 1990s: Missed Opportunities for a New Multilateral Security Order in Europe and Eurasia" in The Euro-Russian Entente: Brussels and Moscow between Convergence and Divergence (1985–1999), edited by Elena Dundovich and Simone Paoli (Routledge, 2026), and "The Kremlin and Foreign Policy Elites: 'De-Putinization' or Continued Cold War?" (with Robert English) in a special edition of Problems of Post-Communism, 2026.
Matthew Evangelista is President White Professor of History and Political Science Emeritus at Cornell University, Ithaca, New York, USA. In Italy he has served on the graduate faculties of the Catholic University of Milan, the University of Roma Tre, and the University of Bologna. His books include Innovation and the Arms Race (1988); Unarmed Forces: The Transnational Movement to End the Cold War (1999); The Chechen Wars: Will Russia Go the Way of the Soviet Union? (2002); Law, Ethics, and the War on Terror (2008); Gender, Nationalism, and War: Conflict on the Movie Screen (2011); Allied Air Attacks and Civilian Harm in Italy, 1940–1945: Bombing among Friends (2023, available for free download here); and edited volumes on topics ranging from the laws of war to Italian politics. Many of his publications are available at https://matthewevangelista.com.
Most threads on Rorotoko begin with our invitation. Any thread can begin with a proposal: you write it with the same prompts every thread answers, and we review it.
Propose a thread →